Creams
At Creams, nestled in the heart of Greencastle, PA, you’ll find a delightful cafe that not only quenches your thirst but also satisfies your cravings. This charming spot offers an array of enticing menu items—from refreshing beverages to hearty breakfast sandwiches and an irresistible selection of ice cream flavors. The inviting atmosphere, paired with friendly staff, makes every visit a memorable experience.
Begin your day with a delicious breakfast round roll sandwich, such as the Bacon Egg and Cheese or Pork Roll Egg and Cheese, each bursting with flavor and served fresh for just $6.75. If you’re in the mood for a cool treat, don’t miss their famous Root Beer Floats or the incredibly rich and creamy house-made ice cream, which has garnered rave reviews from locals. One customer, Nancy Benson, describes Creams as a "HIDDEN GEM," praising the delicious offerings and the clean establishment.
The drink selection at Creams is equally impressive, with highlights like the Shaken Espresso iced drinks ($3.90-$4.45) that promise a delightful caffeine boost, and the refreshing Sweet Tea Refresher for those hot summer days. On a cooler day, warm up with a Chai Tea Latte, capturing the essence of comforting spices that will envelop you in warmth.
Moreover, parents and kids alike love the complimentary arcade, which adds fun to your visit. As customer Stephanie Daniels shared, not only did her family savor delicious subs, but they also enjoyed a sweet ice cream dessert, proving that Creams is a perfect spot for family outings.
The caring nature of the staff is another reason why Creams has become a beloved community hub, as noted by Rita Bingaman, who highlighted the “sweet and caring” employees, alongside the spectacular Grapenut ice cream, calling it the “BEST” she had ever had.
With its unique menu offerings and a heartwarming atmosphere, Creams stands out as more than just a café—it’s a space where memories are made over flavorful food and ice cream delights. If you’re in Greencastle, this hidden gem is calling your name!
- Sweet Tea Refresher 20ozUS$3.90
- Americano Iced 20ozUS$4.45
- Coffee 20ozUS$2.60
- Root Beer Floats 16ozUS$4.20
- Soda Sprite 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Tea Hot 20ozUS$2.60
- Sweet Tea Refresher 16ozUS$3.40
- Lemonade 16ozUS$3.40
- Soda Diet Coke 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Shaken Espresso Iced 16ozUS$3.90
- Latte 20ozUS$4.45
- Dirty Coffee 20ozUS$4.45
- Chai Tea Latte Iced 16ozUS$3.90
- Dirty Coffee 16ozUS$3.90
- Hot Chocolate Iced 20ozUS$3.90
- Americano Iced 16ozUS$3.90
- Lemonade 20ozUS$3.90
- Chai Tea Latte Hot 20ozUS$4.45
- Butter Beer 16ozUS$3.90
- Hot Chocolate 16ozUS$3.90
- Soda Diet Sprite 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Butter Beer 20ozUS$4.45
- Shaken Espresso Iced 20ozUS$4.45
- Latte 16ozUS$3.90
- Coldbrew 20 OzUS$4.45
- Root Beer Floats 20ozUS$4.70
- Strawberry Refresher 16ozUS$3.40
- Soda A&W Rootbeer 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Chai Tea Latte Hot 16ozUS$3.90
- Hot Chocolate Iced 16ozUS$3.40
- Soda Coke 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Milkshake 20ozUS$5.75
- Strawberry Refresher 20ozUS$3.90
- Chai Tea Latte Iced 20ozUS$4.45
- Hot Chocolate 20ozUS$4.45
- Coldbrew 16ozUS$3.90
- Water BottleUS$1.05
- Sunkist 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Tea Hot 16ozUS$2.35
- Sunkist 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Soda Sprite 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Soda Coke 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Soda A&W Rootbeer 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Water BottleUS$1.05
- Soda Diet Sprite 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Soda Diet Coke 16.9ozUS$2.60
- Sub Cheese BurgerUS$11.45
- Sub Roast Beef And CheeseUS$10.40
- Sub Turkey And ProvoloneUS$10.40
- Pork Roll Cheese Round Roll Hot SanwichUS$5.75
- Sub Cheese PizzaUS$5.20
- Cold Cut On RollUS$5.80
- Sub Ham Cappacuolo Salami And CheeseUS$10.40
- Pork Roll And Cheese SubsUS$11.45
- Sub BLTUS$10.40
- Sub Honey Ham Salami And ProvoloneUS$10.40
- Sub Ham Turkey ProvoloneUS$10.40
- Sub Cheese BurgerUS$11.45
- Sub Honey Ham Turkey With SwissUS$10.40
- Pork Roll Egg And Cheese On A Round RollUS$6.75
- Sub Pepperoni Salami And CheeseUS$10.40
- Sub Ham Salami ProvoloneUS$10.40
- Ham Egg And Cheese On A Round RollUS$6.75
- Bacon Egg And Cheese On Round RollUS$6.75
- Pretzel Cinnamon Sugar HotUS$3.65
- Ham Egg And Cheese On A Round RollUS$6.75
- Bacon Egg And Cheese On Round RollUS$6.75
- Pork Roll Egg And Cheese On A Round RollUS$6.75
- Snowball- Two DipUS$2.10
- Slushie 20 OzUS$2.35
- Snowball- One DipUS$1.85
- Slushie 16 OzUS$2.10
- Snowball- Three DipUS$2.35
- Strawberry Refresher 16ozUS$3.40
- Strawberry Refresher 20ozUS$3.90
- Sweet Tea Refresher 20ozUS$3.90
- Dragon Fruit Mango Lemonade 16ozUS$3.40
- Lemonade 20ozUS$3.90
- Dragon Fruit Mango Lemonade 20ozUS$3.90
- Sweet Tea Refresher 16ozUS$3.40
- Lemonade 16ozUS$3.40
- Coldbrew 16ozUS$3.90
- Tea Hot 20ozUS$2.60
- Coldbrew 20 OzUS$4.45
- Americano Iced 16ozUS$3.90
- Chai Tea Latte Hot 20ozUS$4.45
- Tea Hot 16ozUS$2.35
- Shaken Espresso Iced 16ozUS$3.90
- Chai Tea Latte Iced 16ozUS$3.90
- Coffee 20ozUS$2.60
- Americano Iced 20ozUS$4.45
- Chai Tea Latte Iced 20ozUS$4.45
- Shaken Espresso Iced 20ozUS$4.45
- Chai Tea Latte Hot 16ozUS$3.90
- Latte 16ozUS$3.90
- Dirty Coffee 16ozUS$3.90
- Dirty Coffee 20ozUS$4.45
- ChipsUS$0.80
- French FriesUS$3.40
- Baby Cake Potatoes (8)US$3.15
- Salad PotatoUS$3.15
- Frozen Cheescake On A StickUS$4.20
- Cold FoamUS$1.05
- Butter Beer 20ozUS$4.45
- Butter Beer 16ozUS$3.90
- Dubai SundaeUS$8.30
- 1 DipUS$4.20
- 3 DipsUS$6.25
- 2 DipsUS$5.20
- Milkshake 20ozUS$5.75
- Extra Pistachio CreamUS$1.05
25 Reviews
20 Sep 2025
10 Sep 2025
10 Sep 2025
29 Aug 2025
27 Aug 2025
27 Aug 2025
30 Jun 2025
16 Jun 2025
Caffe Trač
The Living
R R R CAFE
CAFE' de POOL
Bash Pelivan
Join the Creams Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.